Safer Recruitment: Are We Asking the Right Questions?

by Catherine Lyon 28/10/2026

Whistleblowing in Early Years

The recent case of Kristian Parry, who used fake references to get jobs in nurseries in Leeds, is worrying and makes us think about how we hire people to work with young children.

Parry had reportedly lost his job at one nursery because of concerns about alcohol use. He then used false references to get a job at another nursery. After his arrest in May 2025, he used false references again to secure a position at a third nursery, despite being on police bail.

In October 2026, he received a further two-year prison sentence for the second fraud offence.

What concerns me is how easily references can apparently be falsified. We know obtaining references is required, but do we always check that they genuinely come from the previous employer? An email can look perfectly legitimate, especially if we use contact details provided by the applicant.

I would also question how thoroughly we explore someone’s employment history. If an applicant has left a previous nursery, do we establish why? And if something doesn’t quite add up, do we pursue it?

Then there is the issue of DBS checks.

The National Day Nurseries Association (NDNA) has raised concerns that the DBS Update Service failed to identify Parry’s arrest and bail conditions. It is now recommending that nurseries obtain fresh enhanced DBS checks before employing new staff.

That may provide additional reassurance, but even an enhanced DBS check does not necessarily reveal an ongoing investigation or every restriction imposed by the police.

I wonder how many nursery managers fully appreciate this.

Having run nurseries myself, I know how much responsibility rests with the person making recruitment decisions. You are expected to establish that someone is suitable to work with children, often while managing staffing pressures and trying to fill vacancies.

But we cannot make informed decisions if we lack important information.

Of course, we must check references properly, question inconsistencies, and never let recruitment procedures become a paperwork exercise. However, there is a limit to what an employer can reasonably discover when someone deliberately sets out to deceive them.

We do not know enough about the recruitment procedures followed by the nurseries involved to judge their actions, and I would be very cautious about doing so.

What we can do is look at our own practices and consider whether there is anything we need to change.

The wider issue is whether the systems designed to support safer recruitment are providing nursery managers with the information they need.

That is where I believe further scrutiny is needed.

Sources: West Yorkshire Police (23 October 2026), BBC News, Yorkshire Evening Post and DBS Update Service guidance.

About the Author

Catherine Lyon is an early years expert with over 50 years of experience across the sector. Her professional foundation began with the NNEB and NNEB Advanced Certificate, and her career has gone on to include leading her own Outstanding and nationally award-winning nurseries, working as an Ofsted inspector, serving as an internal quality assurer for early years qualifications, and setting up a nationally award-winning CACHE Training Centre. Throughout her work, Catherine has remained focused on strengthening early years practice while keeping the child at the centre of decision-making. Her experience spans hands-on practice, leadership, inspection, quality assurance, training, mentoring and consultancy. Read more about Catherine Lyon.